Time to form a Coordination Committee to ensure hassle-free EXIM trade

Port Wings is bringing out series of articles on the major issues pertaining to the EXIM sector every week before the Tamil Nadu Government’s Global Investors Meet (GIM). This week, we analyse about the importance of Coordination between Tamil Nadu and Union Government to ensure EXIM Trade.

Maggi Row: Need of the Hour is the holistic approach

Source: http://www.portwings.in/editorial/maggi-row-need-of-the-hour-is-the-holistic-approach/ 

Editorial in Port Wings, June 10, 2015:

Ever since the Government of India pulled the plug on Nestle product Maggi noodles citing food safety and consumption issues, there has been a hue and cry over the status (rather quality) of MNC products across the country.

As anticipated, media playing its role in fanning the crisis as something happening for the first time in the country.

It was the state of Uttar Pradesh, which cracked down on the otherwise famously know 2-minutes readymade food, first more than a week ago. And the other states, starting from Kashmir to Tamil Nadu joined the band wagon and culminated their zest with either banning the product or forcing the shops to clear the stocks from shelves.

While there is no question about the action that followed the flurry of reactions both online as well as off-line, the issue has opened Pandora ’s Box for the multi-national companies to revisit their strategies in marketing their products in Indian market.

Before the entry of MNCs in food products-related market in India, there were a few Desi players who ruled the market share for years.

With the Globalization, Indian markets were opened for MNCs and it marked the beginning of end of the Desi players. They were unable to withstand the flurry of advertisement campaigns unleashed by the MNCs in promoting their products. After a period, most of the desi players, who were just unable to market their products, started disappearing one by one, and a few merged their businesses with the giant MNCs to stay back in the market.

While the market forces as well as the consumers put blame on the very Desi players for not able to match the quality offered by the MNCs in their products and disappearing from the market, they failed to notice that it was the clear strategy by the MNCs to beat the Desi players through vigorous advertisement campaigns and monopolize the segment with their products later.

Regular drinkers of carbonated drinks offered by a well-known company would tell the difference in the taste of the same brand offered by the company in Singapore, Dubai and in India.

While the company always claimed that it was the outcome of the water sourced in these countries for manufacturing, users know that the company employs a different standards for different countries.

And it is the case with the most of the MNCs in the world’s largest market, who prefer to follow different standards for Indian consumers.

Until now, there were no reports of Indian Food Safety Authority doing regular sample checks on these MNCs products in the country. But the time has now to start implementing stringent measures for both the Desi players as well as MNCs to ensure that consumers get the right products, not the one that has been customized to meet Indian standards.

The crisis also opened an opportunity for the Modi Government to check the quality of products made available to Indian consumers by both Indian as well as Multi-National companies. 

Editorial: Without support from States, Centre cannot deliver on Make-In-India

Source:http://www.portwings.in/editorial/editorial-without-support-from-states-centre-cannot-deliver-on-make-in-india/

Port Wings, June 03, 2015:

During his visits to various countries in the last one year, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had made remarkable strides in convincing the investors over there on Make-In-India to invest in India.

However, his energy in convincing the overseas investors could go to drain if the Union Government is failed to convince the state governments here, who play an important role in land acquisition, relief and rehabilitation processes.

The Constitution of India has not described India as a Federation. On the other hand, Article 1 of the Constitution describes India as a “Union of States.” This means, India is a union comprising of various States which are integral parts of it.

The Constitution of India divides powers between the Union and the State governments. The Seventh Schedule of the Constitution includes three lists of subjects - the Union List, the State List and the Concurrent List. The Central or Union Government has exclusive power to make laws on the subjects which are mentioned in the Union List. The States have the power to make law on the subjects which are included in the Concurrent List. With regard to the Concurrent List, both the Central and State governments can make laws on the subjects mentioned in the Concurrent List.

It may be noted here that in making laws on the subjects of the Concurrent list, the Central government has more authority than the State governments. And on the subjects of the State List also the Central government has indirect control. All this shows that though the Indian Constitution has clearly divided powers between the two governments, yet the Central government has been made stronger than the State governments.

As far as the land acquisition for projects is concerned, the states have the power and the Union Government can only request the states to speed up the process. The recent example is enough to tell the powers of states on the subject, where Anil Ambani-led Reliance Power has terminated the contract for Rs 36K crore Tilaiya ultra mega power project in Jharkhand over inordinate delays in land acquisition.

Under such circumstances, the Union Government led by Modi may convince the big ticket investors in come and invest in India.

However, no big projects can ideally take-off without the integrated support from the respective state governments.

So, it is time for the Prime Minister to take the state governments on board before finalizing any big deal in the foreign soil.

Even though the Union Government holds land banks in most of the states through its Commerce Ministry (SEZ), here too, the state government’s support is ostensibly needed.

So, the Union Government should take the state’s vision, its concerns into account before finalizing any big deal in foreign soil, as the success of such deals solely depends on the state governments.

Improving Investors’ confidence: CM Jaya has her task cutout

As part of the Agenda Setting before the Tamil Nadu Government’s Global Investors Meet (GIM), scheduled to held in the month of September this year, Port Wings has planned to bring out series of articles on the major issues pertaining to the EXIM sector every week. This week, we analyse about the importance of Chennai Port -Maduravoyal Elevated Expressway.

Source: http://www.portwings.in/articlesinterviews/improving-investors-confidence-cm-jaya-has-her-task-cutout/

Port Wings News Network:

The inordinate delay in completing the all-important Chennai Port -Maduravoyal Elevated Expressway, which was primarily conceived as a permanent solution to growing congestion of heavy vehicles (container trailers and vehicles carrying ODC cargoes) plying between Chennai Port and outskirts of city via Chennai’s arterial roads, is not only killing the growth of EXIM trade in the region, but also demoralize the investors’ confidence on the Tamil Nadu state.

As a cascading effect of the defunct project, exporters and importers from Tamil Nadu, who naturally preferred the Chennai Port for their needs for decades, slowly shifting their operations to ports located in neighbouring states.

TESTING TIME FOR TAMIL NADU:

Since the project is now caught in the legal web and its effect is being largely felt on the EXIM trade, Union Minister of Road Transport, Highways and Shipping Mr Nitin Gadkari (during his visit to Tamil Nadu last November) even suggested for an “Out of Court” settlement with the Tamil Nadu Government.

However, nothing has moved since then and the new Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu Ms J Jayalalithaa has her task cut out on the Elevated Expressway project.

According to sources, if the Chief Minister Jayalalithaa speeds up the process and accepts the opinion of Mr Gadkari’s “Out of Court” settlement on the Elevated Expressway Project, it would send a right signal among the potential investors and could help her to harp on the improved image of the Tamil Nadu state in the Global Investors Meet.

According to experts, if the project gets a green signal from the Tamil Nadu government, it would help those EXIM players, who left the Chennai Port in the past due to lack of road connectivity, to rethink on coming back to Chennai Port again.

The project, on completion, will give a seamless and round-the-clock movement of container trailers to and from the Chennai Port. Besides, it will help the port to generate revenue for both the State government as well as the Union Government.

It has been more than three years since the Tamil Nadu State government put a spanner in the 19-km long Chennai Port -Maduravoyal Elevated Expressway project citing slight deviation from approved alignment.

ELEVATED EXPRESSWAY PROJECT:

With a view to alleviate the perennial congestion of heavy vehicles on Chennai’s arterial roads which could create serious problems for other common road users in the future if not arrested on time, major stakeholders — Chennai Port, a Central government-maintained major port, and the Tamil Nadu state government – have planned for a better road connectivity to ensure seamless movement of cargo towards Chennai Port round-the-clock without disturbing common road users.

After much deliberation on the prospective plans for all users – regular motorists as well as heavy vehicles, it was finally decided that an elevated expressway project from Chennai Port upto Maduravoyal, which is the important entry point for all kinds of commercial vehicles to port, should be developed, so that traffic congestion could be arrested in future.

As a next step, the Government of India in December 2008 gave its nod for development of four-lane elevated road from Chennai Port to Maduravoyal under its flagship scheme of National Highways Development Programme (NHDP) Phase VII.

The project,  which started in September 2010 at the behest of Tamil Nadu Government and Chennai Port Trust and due to be completed by September 2013 (as per 2010 schedule) would cut down the travel time between the port and Maduravoyal, on the city outskirts, from more than two hours to just 15-20 minutes.

ADVANTAGES OF THE PROJECT:

Under NHDP Phase VII, the Government of India had approved the construction of standalone ring roads, bypasses, grid separators, flyovers, elevated roads, tunnels, road over bridge, underpasses, service roads, etc. in the Public Private Partnership (PPP) mode.

The need for a dedicated freight road emerged as a better solution, as Chennai Port has experienced a steady increase in the volume of traffic handled over the years, which in turn has increased the traffic on the internal roads of the Port.

The Elevated Expressway project came in to existence due to certain traffic restrictions on movement of heavy vehicles to Chennai Port on NH-4 within Chennai city.

The state government of Tamil Nadu in 2008 also agreed to the alignment of this elevated road and also to carry out the land acquisition, rehabilitation and resettlement on a 50:50 cost basis between the Chennai Port Trust and state government. The Chennai Port Trust would initially bear the entire cost and subsequently 50 % of the cost reimbursed from the state government.

The project has been envisaged to provide an all-time road without any traffic regulatory obstacles so that Port can be approached directly from the outskirts of Chennai city without interfering the city traffic by all commercial vehicles.

For general traffic (non-commercial users), entry/exit ramps are proposed on Kamarajar Salai (Exit), Sivananda Salai (Entry), College Road (Entry) and Spur Tank Road( Exit). The project was planned on Design, Build, Finance, Operate & Transfer (DBFOT) basis and the concession period was decided as 15 years in accordance with the design capacity of the highways. The project has been divided into two

sections. In section -1, road from Chennai Port to Koyambedu – total length 14.2 Km including the ramps at Koyambedu would be developed. In section -2, it was decided that project from Koyambedu to Maduravoyal – widening of NH4 from and elevated road should be carried out.

TUMULTUOUS JOURNEY:

Though the then Prime Minister Mr Manmohan Singh laid foundation stone for the important connectivity project in January 2009, work on the Koyambedu to Maduravoyal section of the Elevated Road began only in September 2010.

The work on the Chennai Port to Koyambedu section started only in March 2011 after receiving the Centre’s CRZ clearance for the section since it runs along the River Cooum, one of the important waterways in city.

Though the implementing authority of the project, NHAI started to fast track the project after so-much undue delays,  Tamil Nadu government put a spanner on its work citing deviation from approved alignment along River Cooum in March 2012. Ever since the objection and “Stop Work” notice by the State’s PWD department, work on the Rs 2000-crore came to a grinding halt.

CAUGHT IN THE LEGAL WEB:

With the project was forced to halt in the face of PWD’s objection, National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has moved the Madras High Court seeking directions to the state authorities to execute it as agreed earlier.

According to the prayer, NHAI sought quashing of a letter by the Chief Engineer of Water Resource Organisation, Public Works Department, asking NHAI to obtain revised Coastal Regulatory Zone (CRZ) clearance for the 19-km long ‘Chennai Port-Maduravoyal Elevated Corridor, and carry out certain remedial measures.

This direction to obtain revised CRZ clearance was nothing but arbitrary exercise of power, malafide against the spirit of public interest and various orders passed by the Tamil Nadu government, NHAI claimed in the petition.

The implementing agency also submitted before the court that though necessary clearances and approvals had been obtained from concerned departments/agencies before commencing the project, after the change of government in May 2011, there has been no cooperation from various departments of the state government with regards to the land acquisition, rehabilitation, resettlement of project affected families.

CHENNAI PORT’S ASSERTION IN COURT:

Besides NHAI, Chennai Port also contended in the Court that the 19-km Chennai Port-Maduravoyal Expressway is of great significance in view of the development of a various productivity enhancing projects in the port.

In a filing before the Madras High Court few months ago, Mr Sunilkumar Madabhavi, Chief Engineer, Chennai Port Trust, pleaded that the total traffic handled by Chennai Port for the last five years, 70 to 80 per cent cargo movement was by through road, of which 60 to 70 per cent road bound cargo was towards the south of the port (towards Maduravoyal due to its proximity to national highways).

The project was not only beneficial for development of Chennai Port but would also help local traffic to use the corridor continuously as there were entry and exit ramps into the corridor for local traffic to reach the Madras High Court, Rajiv Gandhi Government Hospital and Central and Egmore railway stations and other major hospitals located en route the elevated road without passing through congested arterial roads inside the city, the port management contended in the affidavit.

CHANGE OF GOVERNMENT IN STATE:

The alignment was finalised after taking into account all aspects of geometry, optimum utilisation of Cooum boundary and minimum acquisition of private land. The project, along the Cooum River, was mainly designed based on the requirements of the State to suit not only the Port but also that general public.

However, after a change in the government in state in May 2011, there had been no cooperation from the various departments of the State government with regard to land acquisition, rehabilitation and re-settlement of the project-affected families for reasons best known to them.

The authorities concerned were not evincing any interest on this project and became averse to the same. By an order, the Public Works Department had urged the NHAI to obtain revised CRZ clearance and to carry out certain remedial measures such as drudging of 2 metres beyond the outer column and construction of retaining wall for a height of 3 to 5 metres in the extended portion.

Modi is duty-bound to reveal outcome of his foreign tours

Source: http://www.portwings.in/editorial/modi-is-duty-bound-to-reveal-outcome-of-his-foreign-tours/

Port Wings Editorial:

May 27, 2015:

Ever since taking office in May 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has visited Bhutan, Brazil, Nepal, Japan, United States, Myanmar, Australia, Fiji, Nepal, Seychelles, Mauritius, Singapore, France, Germany, Canada, China, Mongolia, and South Korea.

And there are reports coming out from PMO that in another few days time, Modi is expected to fly on another tour.

Modi’s foreign tours have drawn a lot of attention, praise and criticism from various quarters. 

While the main opposition party Indian National Congress has termed the tours as self-promotion of “Brand Modi” than the country he representing as the elected representative, BJP has categorically countered the accusation and stated that PM Modi’s foreign tours are indeed aimed at building a momentum before the global community that India has reached its stature for a greater responsibility and fully deserves a Permanent Seat in the United Nation’s Security Council.

However, given the PMO’s staunch denial to RTI queries seeking details, outcome and expenditures of such tours, the praja, which has voted him to become the Prime Minister of India, asymmetrically   divided over the PM’s frequent foreign tours and its actual results.

The social media, which had helped the Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi to become the Prime Minister of India, last May, has seen a war of words between the sympathizers of BJP and Congress in the last few weeks particularly on Modi’s unwarranted jibes on the Congress Party on foreign soil.

The whole idea of Narendra Modi’s foreign tours came under severe criticism in the social media think-tanks and a few of them even went on to the extent that Modi becomes the flying Prime Minister with no time for visiting the rural India, which has given the BJP party a concrete mandate to govern the world’s largest democracy.

Indeed, a few of those thinkers were right in blaming the denigration of institution, as Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who ought to be present at the Parliament, when it is in session, decided to go on tours giving scant regard to the Temple of Democracy.

Modi’s foreign trips have been highly publicised by media and many have criticised him for ignoring issues back at home, most recent bashing has come from Rahul Gandhi who stated that PM is busy visiting foreign countries very often, but he doesn’t go to the houses of farmers and labourers in India.

Even though the BJP has brought in a battery of spokespersons to defend such voices against the PM’s foreign tours, time has come to tell the real outcome of his foreign tours.

Social media is a regular bashing ground for PM’s trips abroad. The BJP’s line of PM’s foreign trips have been designed to meet India’s foreign policy of improving relations with various nations falls flat on a point that the country has a regular Foreign Minister and she is capable.

Until unless the Prime Minister comes out with a concrete details about the actual outcome on his foreign tours undertaken till now, people will be continue to believe that Modi is indeed touring the world as a tourist using Indian taxpayers’ money.

Pending projects: TN’s Lone Union Minister Pins Hope on Jaya

Source: http://www.portwings.in/articlesinterviews/pending-projects-tns-lone-union-minister-pins-hope-on-jaya/

Chennai:

Port Wings News Network:

In a congratulatory message to Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa, who sworn in as the CM of Tamil Nadu for the record fifth time on May 23, Mr Pon. Radhakrishnan, Minister of State for Road Transport, Highways & Shipping, has said that her return as CM will foster fast-paced and better industrial growth in the of southern coastal state.

Mr Radhakrishnan, who also attended the Jayalalithaa’s swearing-in ceremony as the representative of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, said that many pending port-related projects are likely to be speeded up under the new Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa.

PANNEERSELVAM & RADHAKRISHNAN MEETING:

In an unexpected visit during November last year, Mr Radhakrishnan, who was the then Union Minister of State for Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, met the then Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu Mr O. Panneerselvam at the State Secretariat.

During the meeting, Mr Radhakrishnan, who is the only Minister representing the state of Tamil Nadu in the Union Government,  and Mr Panneerselvam discussed the status of several ongoing port and road-related projects and acquisition of land for some projects.

Later speaking to reporters then, the Minister had stated that they discussed some of the ongoing projects including the Ennore Manali Road Improvement Project, Maduravoyal-Chennai Port Elevated Expressway project.

According to experts, eventhough five months have passed since then, nothing has moved beyond a certain point.

However, Mr Radhakrishnan, who has been now moved to Ministry of Road Transport, Highways & Shipping, pinned hope on the new Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa that she would speed up all those port-related projects, as it would bring a name and fame for the Tamil Nadu government during the proposed Global Investors Meet (GIM) slated for September as the “best destination for investment.”

RENEWED HOPE FOR PORT CONNECTIVITY PROJECTS:

It is worth recalling here that the then UPA Government at the Centre and the Tamil Nadu State Government led by AIADMK were at loggerheads on port connectivity projects like EMRIP and Chennai Port-Maduravoyal Elevated Expressway. However, scenario has changed little bit after the BJP-led Union Government sworn in May 2014.

ENNORE MANALI ROAD IMPROVEMENT PROJECT (EMRIP):

Though the then Union Minister of Shipping Mr G K Vasan was instrumental in revitalizing the defunct EMRIP Project in January 2011, which was conceived in early 2000 and remained a non-starter for years, non-cooperation from the state government had its toll on the important port connectivity project.

However, things have started changing post May 2014after the BJP taking over the Union Government.

As one date, about 85 % of the EMRIP project has been completed and few stretches near Kasimedu along the Ennore Expressway, which falls under the Tamil Nadu Government’s ambit, are still remaining a tumbling block.

In March, Mr Radhakrishnan reviewed the progress of the project and asked the Chennai port management to persuade the Tamil Nadu State Government for early completion.

CHENNAI PORT-MADURAVOYAL ELEVATED EXPRESSWAY PROJECT:

Likewise, Chennai Port-Maduravoyal Elevated Expressway project, another important port connectivity project, is stuck for more than three years.

During a visit to Tamil Nadu last November, Union Minister of Road Transport & Highways, Shipping Mr Nitin Gadkari reviewed the pending port connectivity projects in Chennai and went on an open appeal to the Tamil Nadu government to cooperate with them for speedy implementation in the interest of the nation.

OUT OF COURT SETTLEMENT:

While observing that the issue of Elevated Expressway between Chennai Port and Maduravoyal for providing a dedicated road connectivity to the Port is embroiled in court case, Mr Radhakrishnan, during a review meeting in March this year, had recommended that both NHAI and Tamil Nadu government should make efforts to reach an out of court settlement so that the work can be resumed.

IMPORTANCE OF ELEVATED ROAD PROJECT:

With a view to alleviate the perennial congestion of heavy vehicles on Chennai’s arterial roads which could create serious problems for other common road users in the future if not arrested on time, major stakeholders -- Chennai Port, a Central government-maintained major port, and the Tamil Nadu state government – have planned for a better road connectivity to ensure seamless movement of cargo towards Chennai Port round-the-clock without disturbing common road users.

The need for a dedicated freight road emerged as a better solution, as Chennai Port has experienced a steady increase in the volume of traffic handled over the years, which in turn has increased the traffic on the internal roads of the Port.

The Elevated road connectivity project came in to existence due to certain traffic restrictions on movement of heavy vehicles to Chennai Port on NH-4 within Chennai city.

IMPORTANCE OF COLACHEL PORT:

In the message to CM Jayalalithaa, Mr Radhakrishnan also highlighted that her return as Chief Minister would help to move forward swiftly on establishing a modern and a world-class international port at Colachel Harbour, which is now maintained by the Tamil Nadu Maritime Board.

EXIM TRADE HOPES FOR THE BEST:

Though the meeting between Union Minister Mr Radhakrishnan and then Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Mr Paneerselvam had rekindled the hope for changing signs between Tamil Nadu State government and Union Government, the attendance of Mr Radhakrishnan as the representative of Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Jaya swearing-in on May 23 has further raised the hope among the Exim fraternity in the state.

A few of them even said that Mr Radhakrishnan could meet the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa in the State Secretariat soon to seek her support in completing all pending port-related projects and re-development of Colachel Harbour as a Union-Government managed international standard port.

Thiruvottiyur Parking Yard: Madras HC order puts Chennai Port in a fix

Source:http://www.portwings.in/articlesinterviews/thiruvottiyur-parking-yard-madras-hc-order-puts-chennai-port-in-a-fix/

Port Wings News Network:

With the Madras High Court directing the Tamil Nadu Government as well as the Chennai Port Trust (ChPT) to return 13.93 acres land at Thiruvottiyur, where the latter had developed a parking yard for container trailers, the future of the facility aimed at decongesting the Ennore Expressway leading to the port, now hangs on balance.

Delivering the order on a writ petition filed by Ms R.Revathy, descendant of the said property, Justice C.S.Karnan of Madras High Court directed the Tamil Nadu Government and Chennai Port management to reconvey the land situated at Thiruvottiyur in favour of the petitioner within a period of three months after receiving the original compensation amount with admissible interest thereon from the petitioner.

In other words, the order has put question marks over the future of Chennai Port’s ambitious project – a state-of-the-art Container Trailer Parking Yard-cum Customs Clearance Post for port-bound containers.

 BACKGROUND OF THE CASE:

According to the petitioner, the said piece of land at Thiruvottiyur belong to her ancestor late T.Shanmugam, who is none other than the grandfather of the petitioner's father. Under a family partition between the said T.Shanmugam and his son Mr.T.S.Gopal registered as document No.31 of 1960, the above lands were allotted in favour of Mr.T.S.Gopal.

In the meanwhile, the Government of Tamil Nadu had notified for acquiring the said land for the Thiruvottiyur Municipality (after 2011, the said municipality has been merged with Corporation of Chennai) for the purpose of bore well water supply to the village of Thiruvottiyur and the entire procedure of acquisition was completed and an award has been passed by the land acquisition Tahsildar on April 14, 1964 for Rs.1,53,255.91. Subsequent to the acquisition only a part of land was utilized for the purpose for which the land was acquired.

The Petitioner further stated that because of replenishment of sea water, the water available in the lands is not-portable thus the Government did not proceed with the object for which the land was acquired. 

She further stated in her petition that as per the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette extraordinary publishes section 48-B of the Land Acquisition Act enabling the Government for the reconveyance of lands that are acquired by the Government back to the original owners if the lands are not utilized for the purpose acquired for or any other public Convenience Act has been passed with retrospective effect. 

The petitioner contended that even now the land is lying idle and respondent Municipality has not put up any building or not used for any other public purpose. 

MUNICIPALITY HANDS OVER THE LAND TO CHENNAI PORT:

In the meantime, the Municipality leased out the lands to the Chennai Port Trust for using the same as Container Trailers parking yard.  However, the petitioner contended that the Municipality has got no right or power to lease out the same to the Chennai Port Trust.

With the view to decreasing the congestion of container-laden trailers along Ennore Expressway and Madhavaram to the port, Chennai Port Trust on Nov 29, 2013 inaugurated its parking yard cum seal verification centre at Thiruvottiyur.

In the presence of Central Warehousing Corporation (CWC) managing director Mr B B Patnaik, the then Union Minister of Shipping Mr G K Vasan inaugurated the operations of the Thiruvottiyur Parking Yard by flagging off the first container-laden trailer to the yard.

Chennai Port has developed in the first phase the parking facility for around 250 trailers investing around Rs 6 crores. On full functioning, all Chennai Port bound laden container trailers (barring those which are cleared at CFSs) should first come to the parking yard and after verification of all the documents shall proceed to the port and there would not be any waiting of container lorries in the Ennore Expressway.

COUNTER FROM TAMIL NADU GOVERNMENT:

Reacting to the petition, the Tamil Nadu Government submitted before the HC that the land in question has been acquired as early as 1964 and the proper compensation had been paid to the land owners.  After such land was acquired it was put to the proposed use of drawing bore well water for the Thiruvottiyur village.  Subsequently as stated, due to the intrusion of sea water, the bore wells were abandoned.  Thereafter, the lands are in the possession of the respondents herein and have been used for various public purposes from time to time.

The state government further stated that due to proximity of the lands to the first Container Terminal of the Chennai Port Trust, the lands have been leased to the Chennai Port for parking of the container trailers moving towards the said terminal. The lease deed was executed for three years from 2007 to 2010. After the said lease period ended, the fresh lease deed is to be executed and the administrative process is on.

The state government further stated that the remuneration received from the lease of the lands is being used for the public purposes and is being included in the Municipal Budget for carrying out the various activities of the Municipality under the statute, such as provision of roads, water supply, drainage, licensing, town planning, etc.  The government also termed the statements of the petitioner on possession of the lands is totally false and baseless.

The state government further contented that the provision of Section 48-B of the Land Acquisition Act will come into effect only when the land in question is vested with the State Government.  When once the lands have been acquired and have been vested with the requisitioning body, there is no question of re-conveyance that too when the land is being used for public purposes.

CHENNAI PORT’S CONTENTION BEFORE THE HC:

In reply to the petition, Chennai Port authorities stated that the container trailers are plying between the Port Trust and other destination places resulting in heavy traffic volume.  Now, the containers are parking on the acquired land, which has been leased out to the Port Trust. The Port Trust and the Municipality are in general serving the public.  After arranging these facilities the container vehicles are not parking on the road consequently traffic will not be disturbed.  Now, the public vehicles are in free passage on the road without inconvenience to anyone. 

RESPONDENTS GONE ON APPEAL:

When contacted, Mr C. Harichandran, Secretary, Chennai Port Trust, said that the port management as well as the Tamil Nadu Government (respondents) have gone on appeal against the verdict. “Our appeal is likely to be heard after the vacation,” he added.

WE ARE READY FOR FULL-FLEDGED OPERATION: CWC

Speaking to Port Wings, Mr.A.T.Shankar, Regional Manager, CWC, said that they are waiting for the Customs Notification to begin full-fledged operations from the Thiruvottiyur Container Trailer Parking Yard. “The day Customs gives its nod, all operations would begin from the yard,” he added.